Thoughts on Civilization, Barbarism, and Tribalism

While there may be nits to pick in this piece, it is something worth considering, readers. At the very least it could come in handy for your next story – the consideration of Civilization, Barbarism, and Tribalism is quite interesting. The author makes some good points.

Pin on Germanic War Art

EDITORAL: TRIBESMAN, BARBARIAN, AND CITIZEN

John W. Campbell

In studying history, there are three general, and quite distinguishable levels of culture we can identify. Our own we naturally call “civilized” or “civilization,” with the implication of “completely matured and fully developed.” It happens to be as far as cultures on this planet have gone; what the fourth, fifth, nth levels of culture may be we can’t guess, of course. But judging from history, we can make one pretty high-probability guess—the next stage of development will yield a cultural system that will appear, to us, utterly abhorrent—a system founded on Evil and practicing degradation and repellent immoralities.

That’s the characteristic of every level so far . . . as seen from the immediately preceding level.

To define what I mean by the three so-far known levels, I distinguish Tribal, Barbarian, and Civil cultures; the natives of the three we call Tribesmen, Barbarians, and Citizens. Preceding all three is the preorganized culture level of the “primate horde”—the sort of quasi-organized group found among baboons and monkeys, in the present time.

The Tribal culture—in its never-actually-existent theoretical pure state—is a system of pure ritual and taboo. “Everything that is not forbidden is compulsory.” The objectively observable system stems from an unstated philosophy—which is unstated because the Tribesman doesn’t know philosophy exists, any more than a dog knows logic exists, or a fish knows that biochemistry exists. The philosophy is, essentially precisely that of the Absolute Totalitarian state . . . minus the familiar dictator. That is, in the Tribe, the individual exists for the service of the state. The individual has no value whatever, save as a replaceable plug-in unit in the immortal, ever-existent machinery-organism of the Tribe. No individual exists as an individual—neither Tribal king nor Tribal slave; each is a unit plugged in—temporarily, for all these units wear out and are discarded in a score or two of years—to the eternal Traditional System of the Tribe. The cells in a living organism wear out and are discarded; the organism is, relatively speaking, immortal. So, in the Tribe, the individual is nothing; the Tribe is eternal,

In return for a practically absolute loss of self-identity, the Tribesman is rewarded with security and peace of mind. The Tribal Traditions have The Answers to all possible real problems; nothing can happen that the Tribal Traditions, in their ancient and time-tested wisdom, have not already solved. There are no doubts; there are answers which involve “these tribesmen must die,” but Death is not intolerable. Uncertainty—Doubt—these are the Terrors that live in the Unknown. And against those horrors, the ancient wisdom of the Tribal Traditions stand a strong, sure defense.

Read more….

5 thoughts on “Thoughts on Civilization, Barbarism, and Tribalism

  1. Eh. There’s a series of essays on anthropology that I read (Ship of Fools) before reading this. It’s a bit like Readi g Twain’s essay on Fenimore Cooper before getting on The Last of the Mohicans.

    How does he know that the first tribal cultures (as opposed to some modern ones) were as described? Pure quill Ancient Aliens stuff.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. That’s the guy who wrote “Who Goes There?”!

    Agree that as mindsets, his divisions may have some merit, but as an image of history, it’s utterly absurd reductionist nonsense.

    There are ‘levels’ of civilization, and they produce very different mindsets, but it doesn’t divide up anything like as neatly as he presents (e.g. the ‘low-casualty football-style battles’ is also description of how the Greek City States settled disputes: are we going to claim the Greece of Herodotus and Solon was on a ‘tribal’ level? And how does that square with their extreme admiration and cults of heroes? Also, that style of combat ceased to be used when it ceased to be accepted a settlement of disputes: that is, the Peloponnesian War. I suppose that would count as a repulsive moral crime, but it didn’t fundamentally change the Greek culture in terms of its understanding of humanity and society).

    Or take the Franks: did they transition from Barbarians to the Civilized French (insert joke here) through morally abhorrent acts? No, it was through converting to Christianity and following the logic of their new cultural core-belief over the course of centuries. But they never stopped having a hero-based, individualist society, nor did having such a society preclude a strong sense of law and duty. Ditto for England, Spain, etc. His divisions are *way* overly simplistic.

    Broadly speaking, cultures change (it’s dangerous to think in terms of ‘advancement’ because it tends to beg the question) when they adopt new ideas and work out the implications. But in order to adopt those ideas in the first place, they must have some initial appeal: that is, some harmony with their existing ideas. There’s going to be friction and transgression of old practices, of course, but I don’t think it’s ever going to be a matter of “it’s founded in evil and is utterly abhorrent!” because then it wouldn’t be able to get a foothold in people’s minds in the first place.

    (Also: “The Spanish Conquistadors never achieved anything whatever in the United States area;” Uh…the cities of St. Augustine, San Francisco, San Antonio, etc. would like a word with you, Mr. Campbell)

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Pingback: Friday Flotsam: Another Content Strike, History, and Gross Sex Scenes | Serpent's Den

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s